Several incidents in recent weeks have all the “experts” telling us just what happened and who is responsible. This is a common pitfall for leaders. It’s easy to listen to what others say and act on limited information, then move on to the next problem.
That’s a good way to create new problems.
Instead, effective leaders use a systematic decision making process that ensures the best decisions possible. Through many experiences, crises, and sometimes the patience of good leaders, I’ve developed a decision making process that has always worked. I call it the 3-5-2 Decision Making Process™
Why The 3-5-2 Process™? Time is a critical factor in decision making so I’ve divided the process into three segments. Limited time may preclude doing all 10 steps, but it is important to consider all three categories.
The first segment includes 3 steps to determine the real problem and the time available to address it. These steps may have to be completed very quickly, but must always be completed.
1. Define the time frame. Determine when a decision is required so you can gage how long to spend on the next steps.
2. Define the issue. What is the real problem you’re trying to solve?
3. Gather information. Approach the problem as though you know nothing about it. Learn the facts and don’t let your own opinions cloud what you learn.
The next five steps help find the best solution. They require an open mind and some time so it may not be possible to completely accomplish them. Do has much as time permits.
4. Develop alternatives. There may be several ways to approach a problem. Consider several possibilities but don’t fall in love with one solution yet.
5. Discuss potential solutions. Consult experts and people who will have to implement those solutions.
6. Step back. Step back from the issue and look at it as a disinterested third party. This may be difficult, but it helps you see aspects of potential solutions that you might not have considered.
7. Change your perspective. Consider your potential solution from the point of view of those who will have to implement it or will be affected by it.
8. Set the issue aside. A cooling-off period gives you an opportunity to regain objectivity.
The last two steps are where you will implement your decision.
9. Decide and Implement! Now is the time to pick an alternative and make the decision. This can be harder than it sounds, but it’s your responsibility as a leader. If you have completed the above steps, you probably will make a pretty good decision.
10. Evaluate. Mark a time in the future to check on the problem and solution. Don’t skip this step!
A Word About Bias and Preconceived Ideas
We all have them. Sometimes they come from our upbringing, sometimes from past experiences. Whatever their foundation, biases and preconceived ideas can degrade our ability to effectively deal with problems and will affect our ability to make the right decisions.
So, what should you do?
Whether we like to admit it in public, everyone has some biases. Your biases might be about an individual person, a particular process, or even another team. You must recognize them so you’re aware of times when they might impact your decision making.
Preconceived ideas come from past experience, often bad ones, and are more specifically focused.
Biases and preconceived ideas are data points you should not ignore. However, they are also data points that might be irrelevant or even wrong for the situation at hand. You must actively recognize your biases and preconceived ideas and don’t let them lead you to a bad decision.
Now that you have honestly faced your biases and preconceived notions, use them as a test when evaluating potential solutions. The test is not that you have considered them and tailored your action to them, but that you considered them and ensured they have not led you to make a bad decision.
Learning From Aircraft Mishaps
During my time in the Air Force, I was trained as an aircraft mishap investigator. When there is a major aircraft mishap, an investigating board is convened. There are actually two boards, and that is part of why these investigations were so valuable. The first, the Aircraft Mishap Investigation Board, is chartered to thoroughly investigate the situation and determine the cause of the mishap. This report is privileged so anyone the board interviews can feel free to speak without fear of any adverse action. The report is never released to anyone other than the convening authorities who can take actions based on the report’s recommendations. The board’s findings are used to fix contributing factors in an effort to prevent another mishap.
When the Aircraft Mishap Investigation Board convenes, they literally start from nothing. Even though there had often already been news reports and speculation, the board’s job is to start from a position of complete ignorance of the mishap. As a board member it’s often difficult to set aside preconceived notions and not embrace what initially seems obvious, but that is the only way to ensure members work only from facts rather than speculation. The board can pull in any necessary experts and has full authority to interview people who were involved in or witnessed the mishap.
When they finish their investigation, the board produces a very detailed report which includes pictures; interview transcripts; scientific, engineering, and medical analysis; and a timeline of events. The most important part is a narrative of the mishap and events leading up to it. This section of the report lists all the factors, identifying those the board determines were causal starting from the actual mishap and working backwards. The result is a very comprehensive picture of what happened and why. From those factors the board develops recommendations. These factors and recommendations provide information necessary to make changes to prevent another mishap.
The second board, the Accident Investigation Board is convened only after the Mishap Board completes its work. The Accident Board is provided the technical data compiled by the Mishap Board, but not their findings. They also have full authority to investigate and interview. The big difference is they cannot offer any form of privilege or non-disclosure and their findings are publicly releasable. Their mission is to determine accountability.
This system works very well and is one of the primary sources of the 3-5-2 Process™. The most important aspect is to approach the issue with an open mind and a desire to fix the underlying problems and prevent more problems. Responsibility, or blame, can come later.
Use The 3-5-2 Decision Making Process™ to fix the problem, then focus on accountability.
For a more detailed dive and additional information about decision making with your boss, get Don’t Worry, You Can Do This: The Playbook for New and Experienced Leaders Who Want to be More Effective.
